All Star MVP
| Year | Award Winner | Team |
| 2007 | Ichiro Suzuki | Seattle Mariners |
| 2006 | Michael Young | Texas Rangers |
| 2005 | Miguel Tejada | Baltimore Orioles |
| 2004 | Alfonso Soriano | Texas Rangers |
| 2003 | Garret Anderson | Anaheim Angels |
| 2002 | None selected | |
| 2001 | Cal Ripken Jr. | Baltimore Orioles |
| 2000 | Derek Jeter | New York Yankees |
| 1999 | Pedro Martinez | Boston Red Sox |
| 1998 | Roberto Alomar | Baltimore Orioles |
| 1997 | Sandy Alomar Jr. | Cleveland Indians |
| 1996 | Mike Piazza | Los Angeles Dodgers |
| 1995 | Jeff Conine | Florida Marlins |
| 1994 | Fred McGriff | Atlanta Braves |
| 1993 | Kirby Puckett | Minnesota Twins |
| 1992 | Ken Griffey Jr. | Seattle Mariners |
| 1991 | Cal Ripken Jr. | Baltimore Orioles |
| 1990 | Julio Franco | Texas Rangers |
| 1989 | Bo Jackson | Kansas City Royals |
| 1988 | Terry Steinbach | Oakland Athletics |
| 1987 | Tim Raines | Montreal Expos |
| 1986 | Roger Clemens | Boston Red Sox |
| 1985 | Lamarr Hoyt | San Diego Padres |
| 1984 | Gary Carter | Montreal Expos |
| 1983 | Fred Lynn | California Angels |
| 1982 | Dave Concepcion | Cincinnati Reds |
| 1981 | Gary Carter | Montreal Expos |
| 1980 | Ken Griffey Sr. | Cincinnati Reds |
| 1979 | Dave Parker | Pittsburgh Pirates |
| 1978 | Steve Garvey | Los Angeles |
| 1977 | Don Sutton | Los Angeles |
| 1976 | George Foster | Cincinnati Reds |
| 1975 | Bill Madlock and Jon Matlack | Chicago Cubs and N.Y. Mets |
| 1974 | Steve Garvey | Los Angeles |
| 1973 | Bobby Bonds | San Francisco Giants |
| 1972 | Joe Morgan | Cincinnati Reds |
| 1971 | Frank Robinson | Baltimore Orioles |
| 1970 | Carl Yastrzemski | Boston Red Sox |
| 1969 | Willie McCovey | San Francisco Giants |
| 1968 | Willie Mays | San Francisco Giants |
| 1967 | Tony Perez | Cincinnati Reds |
| 1966 | Brooks Robinson | Baltimore Orioles |
| 1965 | Juan Marichal | San Francisco Giants |
| 1964 | Johnny Callison | Philadelphia Phillies |
| 1963 | Willie Mays | San Francisco Giants |
| 1962 | Maury Wills | Los Angeles Dodgers |
| 1962 | Leon Wagner | Los Angeles Angels |