| Year | Award Winner | League | Team | Position |
| 2010 | Mark Buehrle | American League | P | |
| 2010 | Joe Mauer | American League | C | |
| 2010 | Mark Teixeira | American League | 1B | |
| 2010 | Robinson Cano | American League | 2B | |
| 2010 | Evan Longoria | American League | 3B | |
| 2010 | Derek Jeter | American League | SS | |
| 2010 | Carl Crawford | American League | OF | |
| 2010 | Franklin Gutierrez | American League | OF | |
| 2010 | Ichiro Suzuki | American League | OF | |
| 2010 | Bronson Arroyo | National League | P | |
| 2010 | Yadier Molina | National League | C | |
| 2010 | Albert Pujols | National League | 1B | |
| 2010 | Brandon Phillips | National League | 2B | |
| 2010 | Scott Rolen | National League | 3B | |
| 2010 | Troy Tulowitzki | National League | SS | |
| 2010 | Carlos Gonzalez | National League | OF | |
| 2010 | Michael Bourn | National League | OF | |
| 2010 | Shane Victorino | National League | OF | |
| 2009 | Mark Buehrle | American League | P | |
| 2009 | Joe Mauer | American League | C | |
| 2009 | Mark Teixeira | American League | 1B | |
| 2009 | Placido Polanco | American League | 2B | |
| 2009 | Evan Longoria | American League | 3B | |
| 2009 | Derek Jeter | American League | SS | |
| 2009 | Tori Hunter | American League | OF | |
| 2009 | Adam Jones | American League | OF | |
| 2009 | Ichiro Suzuki | American League | OF | |
| 2009 | Adam Wainwright | National League | P | |
| 2009 | Yadier Molina | National League | C | |
| 2009 | Adrian Gonzalez | National League | 1B | |
| 2009 | Orlando Hudson | National League | 2B | |
| 2009 | Ryan Zimmerman | National League | 3B | |
| 2009 | Jimmy Rollins | National League | SS | |
| 2009 | Matt Kemp | National League | OF | |
| 2009 | Michael Bourn | National League | OF | |
| 2009 | Shane Victorino | National League | OF | |
| 2008 | Mike Mussina | American League | New York | P |
| 2008 | Joe Mauer | American League | Minnesota | C |
| 2008 | Carlos Pena | American League | Tampa Bay | 1B |
| 2008 | Dustin Pedroia | American League | Boston | 2B |
| 2008 | Adrian Beltre | American League | Seattle | 3B |
| 2008 | Michael Young | American League | Texas | SS |
| 2008 | Torii Hunter | American League | Los Angeles | OF |
| 2008 | Ichiro Suzuki | American League | Seattle | OF |
| 2008 | Grady Sizemore | American League | Cleveland | OF |
| 2008 | Greg Maddux | National League | Los Angeles | P |
| 2008 | Yadier Molina | National League | St. Louis | C |
| 2008 | Adrian Gonzalez | National League | San Diego | 1B |
| 2008 | Brandon Phillips | National League | Cincinnati | 2B |
| 2008 | David Wright | National League | New York | 3B |
| 2008 | Jimmy Rollins | National League | Philadelphia | SS |
| 2008 | Carlos Beltran | National League | New York | OF |
| 2008 | Nate McLouth | National League | Pittsburgh | OF |
| 2008 | Shane Victorino | National League | Philadelphia | OF |
| 2007 | Johan Santana | American League | Minnesota Twins | P |
| 2007 | Ivan Rodriguez | American League | Detroit Tigers | C |
| 2007 | Kevin Youkilis | American League | Boston Red Sox | 1B |
| 2007 | Placido Polanco | American League | Detroit Tigers | 2B |
| 2007 | Adrian Beltre | American League | Seattle Mariners | 3B |
| 2007 | Orlando Cabrera | American League | Los Angeles Angeles | SS |
| 2007 | Ichiro Suzuki | American League | Seattle Mariners | OF |
| 2007 | Torii Hunter | American League | Minnesota Twins | OF |
| 2007 | Grady Sizemore | American League | Cleveland Indians | OF |
| 2007 | Greg Maddux | National League | San Diego Padres | P |
| 2007 | Russell Martin | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | C |
| 2007 | Derrek Lee | National League | Chicago Cubs | 1B |
| 2007 | Orlando Hudson | National League | Arizona Diamondbacks | 2B |
| 2007 | David Wright | National League | New York Mets | 3B |
| 2007 | Jimmy Rollins | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | SS |
| 2007 | Carlos Beltran | National League | New York Mets | OF |
| 2007 | Andruw Jones | National League | Atlanta Braves | OF |
| 2007 | Jeff Francoeur | National League | Atlanta Braves | OF |
| 2007 | Aaron Rowand | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | OF |
| 2006 | Kenny Rogers | American League | Detroit Tigers | P |
| 2006 | Ivan Rodriguez | American League | Detroit Tigers | C |
| 2006 | Mark Teixeira | American League | Texas Rangers | 1B |
| 2006 | Mark Grudzielanek | American League | Kansas City Royals | 2B |
| 2006 | Eric Chavez | American League | Oakland A's | 3B |
| 2006 | Deter Jeter | American League | New York Yankees | SS |
| 2006 | Torii Hunter | American League | Minnesota Twins | OF |
| 2006 | Ichiro Suzuki | American League | Seattle Mariners | OF |
| 2006 | Vernon Wells | American League | Toronto Blue Jays | OF |
| 2006 | Greg Maddux | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | P |
| 2006 | Brad Ausmus | National League | Houston Astros | C |
| 2006 | Albert Pujols | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | 1B |
| 2006 | Orlando Hudson | National League | Arizona Diamondbacks | 2B |
| 2006 | Scott Rolen | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | 3B |
| 2006 | Omar Vizquel | National League | San Francisco Giants | SS |
| 2006 | Carlos Beltran | National League | New York Mets | OF |
| 2006 | Mike Cameron | National League | San Diego Padres | OF |
| 2006 | Andruw Jones | National League | Atlanta Braves | OF |
| 2005 | Kenny Rogers | American League | Texas Rangers | P |
| 2005 | Jason Varitek | American League | Boston Red Sox | C |
| 2005 | Mark Teixeira | American League | Texas Rangers | 1B |
| 2005 | Orlando Hudson | American League | Toronto Blue Jays | 2B |
| 2005 | Eric Chavez | American League | Oakland A's | 3B |
| 2005 | Derek Jeter | American League | New York Yankees | SS |
| 2005 | Torii Hunter | American League | Minnesota Twins | OF |
| 2005 | Ichiro Suzuki | American League | Seattle Mariners | OF |
| 2005 | Vernon Wells | American League | Toronto Blue Jays | OF |
| 2005 | Greg Maddux | National League | Chicago Cubs | P |
| 2005 | Mike Matheny | National League | San Francisco Giants | C |
| 2005 | Derrek Lee | National League | Chicago Cubs | 1B |
| 2005 | Luis Castillo | National League | Florida Marlins | 2B |
| 2005 | Mike Lowell | National League | Florida Marlins | 3B |
| 2005 | Omar Vizquel | National League | San Francisco Giants | SS |
| 2005 | Andruw Jones | National League | Atlanta Braves | OF |
| 2005 | Jim Edmonds | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | OF |
| 2005 | Bobby Abreu | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | OF |
| 2004 | Kenny Rogers | American League | Texas Rangers | P |
| 2004 | Ivan Rodriguez | American League | Detroit Tigers | C |
| 2004 | Darin Erstad | American League | Anaheim Angels | 1B |
| 2004 | Bret Boone | American League | Seattle Mariners | 2B |
| 2004 | Eric Chavez | American League | Oakland A's | 3B |
| 2004 | Derek Jeter | American League | New York Yankees | SS |
| 2004 | Torii Hunter | American League | Minnesota Twins | OF |
| 2004 | Ichiro Suzuki | American League | Seattle Mariners | OF |
| 2004 | Vernon Wells | American League | Toronto Blue Jays | OF |
| 2004 | Greg Maddux | National League | Chicago Cubs | P |
| 2004 | Mike Matheny | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | C |
| 2004 | Todd Helton | National League | Colorado Rockies | 1B |
| 2004 | Luis Castillo | National League | Florida Marlins | 2B |
| 2004 | Scott Rolen | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | 3B |
| 2004 | Cesar Izturis | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | SS |
| 2004 | Jim Edmonds | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | OF |
| 2004 | Steve Finley | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | OF |
| 2004 | Andruw Jones | National League | Atlanta Braves | OF |
| 2003 | Mike Mussina | American League | New York Yankees | P |
| 2003 | Benjie Molina | American League | Anaheim Angels | C |
| 2003 | John Olerud | American League | Seattle Mariners | 1B |
| 2003 | Bret Boone | American League | Seattle Mariners | 2B |
| 2003 | Eric Chavez | American League | Oakland A's | 3B |
| 2003 | Alex Rodriguez | American League | Texas Rangers | SS |
| 2003 | Mike Cameron | American League | Seattle Mariners | OF |
| 2003 | Torii Hunter | American League | Minnesota Twins | OF |
| 2003 | Ichiro Suzuki | American League | Seattle Mariners | OF |
| 2003 | Mike Hampton | National League | Atlanta Braves | P |
| 2003 | Mike Matheny | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | C |
| 2003 | Derrek Lee | National League | Florida Marlins | 1B |
| 2003 | Luis Castillo | National League | Florida Marlins | 2B |
| 2003 | Scott Rolen | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | 3B |
| 2003 | Edgar Renteria | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | SS |
| 2003 | Jim Edmonds | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | OF |
| 2003 | Andruw Jones | National League | Atlanta Braves | OF |
| 2003 | Jose Cruz Jr. | National League | San Francisco Giants | OF |
| 2002 | Kenny Rogers | American League | Texas Rangers | P |
| 2002 | Benjie Molina | American League | Anaheim Angels | C |
| 2002 | John Olerud | American League | Seattle Mariners | 1B |
| 2002 | Bret Boone | American League | Seattle Mariners | 2B |
| 2002 | Eric Chavez | American League | Oakland A's | 3B |
| 2002 | Alex Rodriguez | American League | Texas Rangers | SS |
| 2002 | Torii Hunter | American League | Minnesota Twins | OF |
| 2002 | Darin Erstad | American League | Anaheim Angels | OF |
| 2002 | Ichiro Suzuki | American League | Seattle Mariners | OF |
| 2002 | Greg Maddux | National League | Atlanta Braves | P |
| 2002 | Brad Ausmus | National League | Houston Astros | C |
| 2002 | Todd Helton | National League | Colorado Rockies | 1B |
| 2002 | Fernando Vina | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | 2B |
| 2002 | Scott Rolen | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | 3B |
| 2002 | Edgar Renteria | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | SS |
| 2002 | Jim Edmonds | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | OF |
| 2002 | Andruw Jones | National League | Atlanta Braves | OF |
| 2002 | Larry Walker | National League | Colorado Rockies | OF |
| 2001 | Mike Mussina | American League | New York Yankees | P |
| 2001 | Ivan Rodriguez | American League | Texas Rangers | C |
| 2001 | Doug Mientkiewicz | American League | Minnesota Twins | 1B |
| 2001 | Roberto Alomar | American League | Cleveland Indians | 2B |
| 2001 | Eric Chavez | American League | Oakland A's | 3B |
| 2001 | Omar Vizquel | American League | Cleveland Indians | SS |
| 2001 | Mike Cameron | American League | Seattle Mariners | OF |
| 2001 | Torii Hunter | American League | Minnesota Twins | OF |
| 2001 | Ichiro Suzuki | American League | Seattle Mariners | OF |
| 2001 | Greg Maddux | National League | Atlanta Braves | P |
| 2001 | Brad Ausmus | National League | Houston Astros | C |
| 2001 | Todd Helton | National League | Colorado Rockies | 1B |
| 2001 | Fernando Vina | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | 2B |
| 2001 | Scott Rolen | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | 3B |
| 2001 | Orlando Cabrera | National League | Montreal Expos | SS |
| 2001 | Jim Edmonds | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | OF |
| 2001 | Andruw Jones | National League | Atlanta Braves | OF |
| 2001 | Larry Walker | National League | Colorado Rockies | OF |
| 2000 | Kenny Rogers | American League | Texas Rangers | P |
| 2000 | Ivan Rodriguez | American League | Texas Rangers | C |
| 2000 | John Olerud | American League | Seattle Mariners | 1B |
| 2000 | Roberto Alomar | American League | Cleveland Indians | 2B |
| 2000 | Travis Fryman | American League | Cleveland Indians | 3B |
| 2000 | Omar Vizquel | American League | Cleveland Indians | SS |
| 2000 | Darin Erstad | American League | Anaheim Angels | OF |
| 2000 | Bernie Williams | American League | New York Yankees | OF |
| 2000 | Jermaine Dye | American League | Kansas City Royals | OF |
| 2000 | Greg Maddux | National League | Atlanta Braves | P |
| 2000 | Mike Matheny | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | C |
| 2000 | J.T. Snow | National League | San Francisco Giants | 1B |
| 2000 | Pokey Reese | National League | Cincinnati Reds | 2B |
| 2000 | Scott Rolen | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | 3B |
| 2000 | Neifi Perez | National League | Colorado Rockies | SS |
| 2000 | Jim Edmonds | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | OF |
| 2000 | Andruw Jones | National League | Atlanta Braves | OF |
| 2000 | Steve Finley | National League | Arizona Diamondbacks | OF |
| 1999 | Mike Mussina | American League | Baltimore Orioles | P |
| 1999 | Ivan Rodriguez | American League | Texas Rangers | C |
| 1999 | Rafael Palmeiro | American League | Texas Rangers | 1B |
| 1999 | Roberto Alomar | American League | Cleveland Indians | 2B |
| 1999 | Scott Brosius | American League | New York Yankees | 3B |
| 1999 | Omar Vizquel | American League | Cleveland Indians | SS |
| 1999 | Ken Griffey, Jr. | American League | Seattle Mariners | OF |
| 1999 | Bernie Williams | American League | New York Yankees | OF |
| 1999 | Shawn Green | American League | Toronto Blue Jays | OF |
| 1999 | Greg Maddux | National League | Atlanta Braves | P |
| 1999 | Mike Lieberthal | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | C |
| 1999 | J.T. Snow | National League | San Francisco Giants | 1B |
| 1999 | Pokey Reese | National League | Cincinnati Reds | 2B |
| 1999 | Robin Ventura | National League | New York Mets | 3B |
| 1999 | Rey Ordonez | National League | New York Mets | SS |
| 1999 | Andruw Jones | National League | Atlanta Braves | OF |
| 1999 | Steve Finley | National League | Arizona Diamondbacks | OF |
| 1999 | Larry Walker | National League | Colorado Rockies | OF |
| 1998 | Mike Mussina | American League | Baltimore Orioles | P |
| 1998 | Ivan Rodriguez | American League | Texas Rangers | C |
| 1998 | Rafael Palmeiro | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 1B |
| 1998 | Roberto Alomar | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 2B |
| 1998 | Robin Ventura | American League | Chicago | 3B |
| 1998 | Omar Vizquel | American League | Cleveland Indians | SS |
| 1998 | Ken Griffey, Jr. | American League | Seattle Mariners | OF |
| 1998 | Bernie Williams | American League | New York Yankees | OF |
| 1998 | Jim Edmonds | American League | Anaheim Angels | OF |
| 1998 | Greg Maddux | National League | Atlanta Braves | P |
| 1998 | Charles Johnson | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | C |
| 1998 | J.T. Snow | National League | San Francisco Giants | 1B |
| 1998 | Bret Boone | National League | Cincinnati Reds | 2B |
| 1998 | Scott Rolen | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | 3B |
| 1998 | Rey Ordonez | National League | New York Mets | SS |
| 1998 | Larry Walker | National League | Colorado Rockies | OF |
| 1998 | Andruw Jones | National League | Atlanta Braves | OF |
| 1998 | Barry Bonds | National League | San Francisco Giants | OF |
| 1997 | Mike Mussina | American League | Baltimore Orioles | P |
| 1997 | Ivan Rodriguez | American League | Texas Rangers | C |
| 1997 | Rafael Palmeiro | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 1B |
| 1997 | Chuck Knoblauch | American League | Minnesota Twins | 2B |
| 1997 | Matt Williams | American League | Cleveland Indians | 3B |
| 1997 | Omar Vizquel | American League | Cleveland Indians | SS |
| 1997 | Ken Griffey, Jr. | American League | Seattle Mariners | OF |
| 1997 | Jim Edmonds | American League | Anaheim Angels | OF |
| 1997 | Bernie Williams | American League | New York Yankees | OF |
| 1997 | Greg Maddux | National League | Atlanta Braves | P |
| 1997 | Charles Johnson | National League | Florida Marlins | C |
| 1997 | J.T. Snow | National League | San Francisco Giants | 1B |
| 1997 | Craig Biggio | National League | Houston Astros | 2B |
| 1997 | Ken Caminiti | National League | San Diego Padres | 3B |
| 1997 | Rey Ordonez | National League | New York Mets | SS |
| 1997 | Barry Bonds | National League | San Francisco Giants | OF |
| 1997 | Raul Mondesi | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | OF |
| 1997 | Larry Walker | National League | Colorado Rockies | OF |
| 1996 | Mike Mussina | American League | Baltimore Orioles | P |
| 1996 | Ivan Rodriguez | American League | Texas Rangers | C |
| 1996 | J.T. Snow | American League | California Angels | 1B |
| 1996 | Roberto Alomar | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 2B |
| 1996 | Robin Ventura | American League | Chicago | 3B |
| 1996 | Omar Vizquel | American League | Cleveland Indians | SS |
| 1996 | Ken Griffey, Jr. | American League | Seattle Mariners | OF |
| 1996 | Kenny Lofton | American League | Cleveland Indians | OF |
| 1996 | Jay Buhner | American League | Seattle Mariners | OF |
| 1996 | Greg Maddux | National League | Atlanta Braves | P |
| 1996 | Charles Johnson | National League | Florida Marlins | C |
| 1996 | Mark Grace | National League | Chicago Cubs | 1B |
| 1996 | Craig Biggio | National League | Houston Astros | 2B |
| 1996 | Ken Caminiti | National League | San Diego Padres | 3B |
| 1996 | Barry Larkin | National League | Cincinnati Reds | SS |
| 1996 | Barry Bonds | National League | San Francisco Giants | OF |
| 1996 | Marquis Grissom | National League | Atlanta Braves | OF |
| 1996 | Steve Finley | National League | San Diego Padres | OF |
| 1995 | Mark Langston | American League | California Angels | P |
| 1995 | Ivan Rodriguez | American League | Texas Rangers | C |
| 1995 | J.T. Snow | American League | California Angels | 1B |
| 1995 | Roberto Alomar | American League | Toronto Blue Jays | 2B |
| 1995 | Wade Boggs | American League | New York Yankees | 3B |
| 1995 | Omar Vizquel | American League | Cleveland Indians | SS |
| 1995 | Ken Griffey, Jr. | American League | Seattle Mariners | OF |
| 1995 | Kenny Lofton | American League | Cleveland Indians | OF |
| 1995 | Devon White | American League | Toronto Blue Jays | OF |
| 1995 | Greg Maddux | National League | Atlanta Braves | P |
| 1995 | Charles Johnson | National League | Florida Marlins | C |
| 1995 | Mark Grace | National League | Chicago Cubs | 1B |
| 1995 | Craig Biggio | National League | Houston Astros | 2B |
| 1995 | Ken Caminiti | National League | San Diego Padres | 3B |
| 1995 | Barry Larkin | National League | Cincinnati Reds | SS |
| 1995 | Steve Finley | National League | San Diego Padres | OF |
| 1995 | Marquis Grissom | National League | Atlanta Braves | OF |
| 1995 | Raul Mondesi | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | OF |
| 1994 | Mark Langston | American League | California Angels | P |
| 1994 | Ivan Rodriguez | American League | Texas Rangers | C |
| 1994 | Don Mattingly | American League | New York Yankees | 1B |
| 1994 | Roberto Alomar | American League | Toronto Blue Jays | 2B |
| 1994 | Wade Boggs | American League | New York Yankees | 3B |
| 1994 | Omar Vizquel | American League | Cleveland Indians | SS |
| 1994 | Ken Griffey, Jr. | American League | Seattle Mariners | OF |
| 1994 | Kenny Lofton | American League | Cleveland Indians | OF |
| 1994 | Devon White | American League | Toronto Blue Jays | OF |
| 1994 | Greg Maddux | National League | Atlanta Braves | P |
| 1994 | Tom Pagnozzi | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | C |
| 1994 | Jeff Bagwell | National League | Houston Astros | 1B |
| 1994 | Craig Biggio | National League | Houston Astros | 2B |
| 1994 | Matt Williams | National League | San Francisco Giants | 3B |
| 1994 | Barry Larkin | National League | Cincinnati Reds | SS |
| 1994 | Barry Bonds | National League | San Francisco Giants | OF |
| 1994 | Marquis Grissom | National League | Montreal Expos | OF |
| 1994 | Darren Lewis | National League | San Francisco Giants | OF |
| 1993 | Mark Langston | American League | California Angels | P |
| 1993 | Ivan Rodriguez | American League | Texas Rangers | C |
| 1993 | Don Mattingly | American League | New York Yankees | 1B |
| 1993 | Roberto Alomar | American League | Toronto Blue Jays | 2B |
| 1993 | Robin Ventura | American League | Chicago | 3B |
| 1993 | Omar Vizquel | American League | Seattle Mariners | SS |
| 1993 | Ken Griffey, Jr. | American League | Seattle Mariners | OF |
| 1993 | Kenny Lofton | American League | Cleveland Indians | OF |
| 1993 | Devon White | American League | Toronto Blue Jays | OF |
| 1993 | Greg Maddux | National League | Atlanta Braves | P |
| 1993 | Kirt Manwaring | National League | San Francisco Giants | C |
| 1993 | Mark Grace | National League | Chicago Cubs | 1B |
| 1993 | Robby Thompson | National League | San Francisco Giants | 2B |
| 1993 | Matt Williams | National League | San Francisco Giants | 3B |
| 1993 | Jay Bell | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | SS |
| 1993 | Barry Bonds | National League | San Francisco Giants | OF |
| 1993 | Marquis Grissom | National League | Montreal Expos | OF |
| 1993 | Larry Walker | National League | Montreal Expos | OF |
| 1992 | Mark Langston | American League | California Angels | P |
| 1992 | Ivan Rodriguez | American League | Texas Rangers | C |
| 1992 | Don Mattingly | American League | New York Yankees | 1B |
| 1992 | Roberto Alomar | American League | Toronto Blue Jays | 2B |
| 1992 | Robin Ventura | American League | Chicago | 3B |
| 1992 | Cal Ripken, Jr. | American League | Baltimore Orioles | SS |
| 1992 | Ken Griffey, Jr. | American League | Seattle Mariners | OF |
| 1992 | Devon White | American League | Toronto Blue Jays | OF |
| 1992 | Kirby Puckett | American League | Minnesota Twins | OF |
| 1992 | Greg Maddux | National League | Chicago Cubs | P |
| 1992 | Tom Pagnozzi | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | C |
| 1992 | Mark Grace | National League | Chicago Cubs | 1B |
| 1992 | Jose Lind | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | 2B |
| 1992 | Terry Pendleton | National League | Atlanta Braves | 3B |
| 1992 | Ozzie Smith | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | SS |
| 1992 | Andy Van Slyke | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | OF |
| 1992 | Barry Bonds | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | OF |
| 1992 | Larry Walker | National League | Montreal Expos | OF |
| 1991 | Mark Langston | American League | California Angels | P |
| 1991 | Tony Pena | American League | Boston Red Sox | C |
| 1991 | Don Mattingly | American League | New York Yankees | 1B |
| 1991 | Roberto Alomar | American League | Toronto Blue Jays | 2B |
| 1991 | Robin Ventura | American League | Chicago | 3B |
| 1991 | Cal Ripken, Jr. | American League | Baltimore Orioles | SS |
| 1991 | Ken Griffey, Jr. | American League | Seattle Mariners | OF |
| 1991 | Devon White | American League | Toronto Blue Jays | OF |
| 1991 | Kirby Puckett | American League | Minnesota Twins | OF |
| 1991 | Greg Maddux | National League | Chicago Cubs | P |
| 1991 | Tom Pagnozzi | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | C |
| 1991 | Will Clark | National League | San Francisco Giants | 1B |
| 1991 | Ryne Sandberg | National League | Chicago Cubs | 2B |
| 1991 | Matt Williams | National League | San Francisco Giants | 3B |
| 1991 | Ozzie Smith | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | SS |
| 1991 | Andy Van Slyke | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | OF |
| 1991 | Barry Bonds | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | OF |
| 1991 | Tony Gwynn | National League | San Diego Padres | OF |
| 1990 | Mike Boddicker | American League | Boston Red Sox | P |
| 1990 | Sandy Alomar, Jr. | American League | Cleveland Indians | C |
| 1990 | Mark McGwire | American League | Oakland A's | 1B |
| 1990 | Harold Reynolds | American League | Seattle Mariners | 2B |
| 1990 | Kelly Gruber | American League | Toronto Blue Jays | 3B |
| 1990 | Ozzie Guillen | American League | Chicago | SS |
| 1990 | Ellis Burks | American League | Boston Red Sox | OF |
| 1990 | Ken Griffey, Jr. | American League | Seattle Mariners | OF |
| 1990 | Gary Pettis | American League | Texas Rangers | OF |
| 1990 | Greg Maddux | National League | Chicago Cubs | P |
| 1990 | Benito Santiago | National League | San Diego Padres | C |
| 1990 | Andres Galarraga | National League | Montreal Expos | 1B |
| 1990 | Ryne Sandberg | National League | Chicago Cubs | 2B |
| 1990 | Tim Wallach | National League | Montreal Expos | 3B |
| 1990 | Ozzie Smith | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | SS |
| 1990 | Barry Bonds | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | OF |
| 1990 | Tony Gwynn | National League | San Diego Padres | OF |
| 1990 | Andy Van Slyke | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | OF |
| 1989 | Bret Saberhagen | American League | Kansas City Royals | P |
| 1989 | Bob Boone | American League | Kansas City Royals | C |
| 1989 | Don Mattingly | American League | New York Yankees | 1B |
| 1989 | Harold Reynolds | American League | Seattle Mariners | 2B |
| 1989 | Gary Gaetti | American League | Minnesota Twins | 3B |
| 1989 | Tony Fernandez | American League | Toronto Blue Jays | SS |
| 1989 | Gary Pettis | American League | Detroit Tigers | OF |
| 1989 | Kirby Puckett | American League | Minnesota Twins | OF |
| 1989 | Devon White | American League | California Angels | OF |
| 1989 | Ron Darling | National League | New York Mets | P |
| 1989 | Benito Santiago | National League | San Diego Padres | C |
| 1989 | Andres Galarraga | National League | Montreal Expos | 1B |
| 1989 | Ryne Sandberg | National League | Chicago Cubs | 2B |
| 1989 | Terry Pendleton | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | 3B |
| 1989 | Ozzie Smith | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | SS |
| 1989 | Eric Davis | National League | Cincinnati Reds | OF |
| 1989 | Tony Gwynn | National League | San Diego Padres | OF |
| 1989 | Andy Van Slyke | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | OF |
| 1988 | Mark Langston | American League | Seattle Mariners | P |
| 1988 | Bob Boone | American League | California Angels | C |
| 1988 | Don Mattingly | American League | New York Yankees | 1B |
| 1988 | Harold Reynolds | American League | Seattle Mariners | 2B |
| 1988 | Gary Gaetti | American League | Minnesota Twins | 3B |
| 1988 | Tony Fernandez | American League | Toronto Blue Jays | SS |
| 1988 | Devon White | American League | California Angels | OF |
| 1988 | Gary Pettis | American League | California Angels | OF |
| 1988 | Kirby Puckett | American League | Minnesota Twins | OF |
| 1988 | Orel Hershiser | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | P |
| 1988 | Benito Santiago | National League | San Diego Padres | C |
| 1988 | Keith Hernandez | National League | New York Mets | 1B |
| 1988 | Ryne Sandberg | National League | Chicago Cubs | 2B |
| 1988 | Tim Wallach | National League | Montreal Expos | 3B |
| 1988 | Ozzie Smith | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | SS |
| 1988 | Andre Dawson | National League | Chicago Cubs | OF |
| 1988 | Eric Davis | National League | Cincinnati Reds | OF |
| 1988 | Andy Van Slyke | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | OF |
| 1987 | Mark Langston | American League | Seattle Mariners | P |
| 1987 | Bob Boone | American League | California Angels | C |
| 1987 | Don Mattingly | American League | New York Yankees | 1B |
| 1987 | Frank White | American League | Kansas City Royals | 2B |
| 1987 | Gary Gaetti | American League | Minnesota Twins | 3B |
| 1987 | Tony Fernandez | American League | Toronto Blue Jays | SS |
| 1987 | Jesse Barfield | American League | Toronto Blue Jays | OF |
| 1987 | Kirby Puckett | American League | Minnesota Twins | OF |
| 1987 | Dave Winfield | American League | New York Yankees | OF |
| 1987 | Rick Reuschel | National League | San Francisco Giants | P |
| 1987 | Mike LaValliere | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | C |
| 1987 | Keith Hernandez | National League | New York Mets | 1B |
| 1987 | Ryne Sandberg | National League | Chicago Cubs | 2B |
| 1987 | Terry Pendleton | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | 3B |
| 1987 | Ozzie Smith | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | SS |
| 1987 | Eric Davis | National League | Cincinnati Reds | OF |
| 1987 | Andre Dawson | National League | Chicago Cubs | OF |
| 1987 | Tony Gwynn | National League | San Diego Padres | OF |
| 1986 | Ron Guidry | American League | New York Yankees | P |
| 1986 | Bob Boone | American League | California Angels | C |
| 1986 | Don Mattingly | American League | New York Yankees | 1B |
| 1986 | Frank White | American League | Kansas City Royals | 2B |
| 1986 | Gary Gaetti | American League | Minnesota Twins | 3B |
| 1986 | Tony Fernandez | American League | Toronto Blue Jays | SS |
| 1986 | Jesse Barfield | American League | Toronto Blue Jays | OF |
| 1986 | Kirby Puckett | American League | Minnesota Twins | OF |
| 1986 | Gary Pettis | American League | California Angels | OF |
| 1986 | F. Valenzuela | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | P |
| 1986 | Jody Davis | National League | Chicago Cubs | C |
| 1986 | Keith Hernandez | National League | New York Mets | 1B |
| 1986 | Ryne Sandberg | National League | Chicago Cubs | 2B |
| 1986 | Mike Schmidt | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | 3B |
| 1986 | Ozzie Smith | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | SS |
| 1986 | Dale Murphy | National League | Atlanta Braves | OF |
| 1986 | Willie McGee | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | OF |
| 1986 | Tony Gwynn | National League | San Diego Padres | OF |
| 1985 | Ron Guidry | American League | New York Yankees | P |
| 1985 | Lance Parrish | American League | Detroit Tigers | C |
| 1985 | Don Mattingly | American League | New York Yankees | 1B |
| 1985 | Lou Whitaker | American League | Detroit Tigers | 2B |
| 1985 | George Brett | American League | Kansas City Royals | 3B |
| 1985 | Alfredo Griffin | American League | Oakland A's | SS |
| 1985 | Gary Pettis | American League | California Angels | OF |
| 1985 | Dave Winfield | American League | New York Yankees | OF |
| 1985 | Dwight Evans | American League | Boston Red Sox | OF |
| 1985 | Dwayne Murphy | American League | Oakland A's | OF |
| 1985 | Rick Reuschel | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | P |
| 1985 | Tony Pena | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | C |
| 1985 | Keith Hernandez | National League | New York Mets | 1B |
| 1985 | Ryne Sandberg | National League | Chicago Cubs | 2B |
| 1985 | Tim Wallach | National League | Montreal Expos | 3B |
| 1985 | Ozzie Smith | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | SS |
| 1985 | Willie McGee | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | OF |
| 1985 | Andre Dawson | National League | Montreal Expos | OF |
| 1985 | Dale Murphy | National League | Atlanta Braves | OF |
| 1984 | Ron Guidry | American League | New York Yankees | P |
| 1984 | Lance Parrish | American League | Detroit Tigers | C |
| 1984 | Eddie Murray | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 1B |
| 1984 | Lou Whitaker | American League | Detroit Tigers | 2B |
| 1984 | Buddy Bell | American League | Texas Rangers | 3B |
| 1984 | Alan Trammell | American League | Detroit Tigers | SS |
| 1984 | Dwight Evans | American League | Boston Red Sox | OF |
| 1984 | Dave Winfield | American League | New York Yankees | OF |
| 1984 | Dwayne Murphy | American League | Oakland A's | OF |
| 1984 | Joaquin Andujar | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | P |
| 1984 | Tony Pena | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | C |
| 1984 | Keith Hernandez | National League | New York Mets | 1B |
| 1984 | Ryne Sandberg | National League | Chicago Cubs | 2B |
| 1984 | Mike Schmidt | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | 3B |
| 1984 | Ozzie Smith | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | SS |
| 1984 | Dale Murphy | National League | Atlanta Braves | OF |
| 1984 | Bob Dernier | National League | Chicago Cubs | OF |
| 1984 | Andre Dawson | National League | Montreal Expos | OF |
| 1983 | Ron Guidry | American League | New York Yankees | P |
| 1983 | Lance Parrish | American League | Detroit Tigers | C |
| 1983 | Eddie Murray | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 1B |
| 1983 | Lou Whitaker | American League | Detroit Tigers | 2B |
| 1983 | Buddy Bell | American League | Texas Rangers | 3B |
| 1983 | Alan Trammell | American League | Detroit Tigers | SS |
| 1983 | Dwight Evans | American League | Boston Red Sox | OF |
| 1983 | Dave Winfield | American League | New York Yankees | OF |
| 1983 | Dwayne Murphy | American League | Oakland A's | OF |
| 1983 | Phil Niekro | National League | Atlanta Braves | P |
| 1983 | Tony Pena | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | C |
| 1983 | Keith Hernandez | National League | St. Louis Cardinals/New York | 1B |
| 1983 | Ryne Sandberg | National League | Chicago Cubs | 2B |
| 1983 | Mike Schmidt | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | 3B |
| 1983 | Ozzie Smith | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | SS |
| 1983 | Andre Dawson | National League | Montreal Expos | OF |
| 1983 | Dale Murphy | National League | Atlanta Braves | OF |
| 1983 | Willie McGee | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | OF |
| 1982 | Ron Guidry | American League | New York Yankees | P |
| 1982 | Bob Boone | American League | California Angels | C |
| 1982 | Eddie Murray | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 1B |
| 1982 | Frank White | American League | Kansas City Royals | 2B |
| 1982 | Buddy Bell | American League | Texas Rangers | 3B |
| 1982 | Robin Yount | American League | Milwaukee Brewers | SS |
| 1982 | Dwight Evans | American League | Boston Red Sox | OF |
| 1982 | Dave Winfield | American League | New York Yankees | OF |
| 1982 | Dwayne Murphy | American League | Oakland A's | OF |
| 1982 | Phil Niekro | National League | Atlanta Braves | P |
| 1982 | Gary Carter | National League | Montreal Expos | C |
| 1982 | Keith Hernandez | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | 1B |
| 1982 | Manny Trillo | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | 2B |
| 1982 | Mike Schmidt | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | 3B |
| 1982 | Ozzie Smith | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | SS |
| 1982 | Andre Dawson | National League | Montreal Expos | OF |
| 1982 | Dale Murphy | National League | Atlanta Braves | OF |
| 1982 | Garry Maddox | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | OF |
| 1981 | Mike Norris | American League | Oakland A's | P |
| 1981 | Jim Sundberg | American League | Texas Rangers | C |
| 1981 | Mike Squires | American League | Chicago White Sox | 1B |
| 1981 | Frank White | American League | Kansas City Royals | 2B |
| 1981 | Buddy Bell | American League | Texas Rangers | 3B |
| 1981 | Alan Trammell | American League | Detroit Tigers | SS |
| 1981 | Dwayne Murphy | American League | Oakland A's | OF |
| 1981 | Dwight Evans | American League | Boston Red Sox | OF |
| 1981 | Rickey Henderson | American League | Oakland A's | OF |
| 1981 | Steve Carlton | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | P |
| 1981 | Gary Carter | National League | Montreal Expos | C |
| 1981 | Keith Hernandez | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | 1B |
| 1981 | Manny Trillo | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | 2B |
| 1981 | Mike Schmidt | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | 3B |
| 1981 | Ozzie Smith | National League | San Diego Padres | SS |
| 1981 | Andre Dawson | National League | Montreal Expos | OF |
| 1981 | Garry Maddox | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | OF |
| 1981 | Dusty Baker | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | OF |
| 1980 | Mike Norris | American League | Oakland A's | P |
| 1980 | Jim Sundberg | American League | Texas Rangers | C |
| 1980 | Cecil Cooper | American League | Milwaukee Brewers | 1B |
| 1980 | Frank White | American League | Kansas City Royals | 2B |
| 1980 | Buddy Bell | American League | Texas Rangers | 3B |
| 1980 | Alan Trammell | American League | Detroit Tigers | SS |
| 1980 | Fred Lynn | American League | Boston Red Sox | OF |
| 1980 | Dwayne Murphy | American League | Oakland A's | OF |
| 1980 | Willie Wilson | American League | Kansas City Royals | OF |
| 1980 | Phil Niekro | National League | Atlanta Braves | P |
| 1980 | Gary Carter | National League | Montreal Expos | C |
| 1980 | Keith Hernandez | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | 1B |
| 1980 | Doug Flynn | National League | New York Mets | 2B |
| 1980 | Mike Schmidt | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | 3B |
| 1980 | Ozzie Smith | National League | San Diego Padres | SS |
| 1980 | Andre Dawson | National League | Montreal Expos | OF |
| 1980 | Garry Maddox | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | OF |
| 1980 | Dave Winfield | National League | San Diego Padres | OF |
| 1979 | Jim Palmer | American League | Baltimore Orioles | P |
| 1979 | Jim Sundberg | American League | Texas Rangers | C |
| 1979 | Cecil Cooper | American League | Milwaukee Brewers | 1B |
| 1979 | Frank White | American League | Kansas City Royals | 2B |
| 1979 | Buddy Bell | American League | Texas Rangers | 3B |
| 1979 | Rick Burleson | American League | Boston Red Sox | SS |
| 1979 | Dwight Evans | American League | Boston Red Sox | OF |
| 1979 | Sixto Lezcano | American League | Milwaukee Brewers | OF |
| 1979 | Fred Lynn | American League | Boston Red Sox | OF |
| 1979 | Phil Niekro | National League | Atlanta Braves | P |
| 1979 | Bob Boone | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | C |
| 1979 | Keith Hernandez | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | 1B |
| 1979 | Manny Trillo | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | 2B |
| 1979 | Mike Schmidt | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | 3B |
| 1979 | Dave Concepcion | National League | Cincinnati Reds | SS |
| 1979 | Garry Maddox | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | OF |
| 1979 | Dave Parker | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | OF |
| 1979 | Dave Winfield | National League | San Diego Padres | OF |
| 1978 | Jim Palmer | American League | Baltimore Orioles | P |
| 1978 | Jim Sundberg | American League | Texas Rangers | C |
| 1978 | Chris Chambliss | American League | New York Yankees | 1B |
| 1978 | Frank White | American League | Kansas City Royals | 2B |
| 1978 | Graig Nettles | American League | New York Yankees | 3B |
| 1978 | Mark Belanger | American League | Baltimore Orioles | SS |
| 1978 | Dwight Evans | American League | Boston Red Sox | OF |
| 1978 | Rick Miller | American League | California Angels | OF |
| 1978 | Fred Lynn | American League | Boston Red Sox | OF |
| 1978 | Phil Niekro | National League | Atlanta Braves | P |
| 1978 | Bob Boone | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | C |
| 1978 | Keith Hernandez | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | 1B |
| 1978 | Davey Lopes | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | 2B |
| 1978 | Mike Schmidt | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | 3B |
| 1978 | Larry Bowa | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | SS |
| 1978 | Garry Maddox | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | OF |
| 1978 | Dave Parker | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | OF |
| 1978 | Ellis Valentine | National League | Montreal Expos | OF |
| 1977 | Jim Palmer | American League | Baltimore Orioles | P |
| 1977 | Jim Sundberg | American League | Texas Rangers | C |
| 1977 | Jim Spencer | American League | Chicago White Sox | 1B |
| 1977 | Frank White | American League | Kansas City Royals | 2B |
| 1977 | Graig Nettles | American League | New York Yankees | 3B |
| 1977 | Mark Belanger | American League | Baltimore Orioles | SS |
| 1977 | Carl Yastrzemski | American League | Boston Red Sox | OF |
| 1977 | Juan Beniquez | American League | Texas Rangers | OF |
| 1977 | Al Cowens | American League | Kansas City Royals | OF |
| 1977 | Jim Kaat | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | P |
| 1977 | Johnny Bench | National League | Cincinnati Reds | C |
| 1977 | Steve Garvey | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | 1B |
| 1977 | Joe Morgan | National League | Cincinnati Reds | 2B |
| 1977 | Mike Schmidt | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | 3B |
| 1977 | Dave Concepcion | National League | Cincinnati Reds | SS |
| 1977 | Garry Maddox | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | OF |
| 1977 | Dave Parker | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | OF |
| 1977 | Cesar Geronimo | National League | Cincinnati Reds | OF |
| 1976 | Jim Palmer | American League | Baltimore Orioles | P |
| 1976 | Jim Sundberg | American League | Texas Rangers | C |
| 1976 | George Scott | American League | Milwaukee Brewers | 1B |
| 1976 | Bobby Grich | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 2B |
| 1976 | Aurelio Rodriguez | American League | Detroit Tigers | 3B |
| 1976 | Mark Belanger | American League | Baltimore Orioles | SS |
| 1976 | Dwight Evans | American League | Boston Red Sox | OF |
| 1976 | Rick Manning | American League | Cleveland Indians | OF |
| 1976 | Joe Rudi | American League | Oakland A's | OF |
| 1976 | Jim Kaat | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | P |
| 1976 | Johnny Bench | National League | Cincinnati Reds | C |
| 1976 | Steve Garvey | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | 1B |
| 1976 | Joe Morgan | National League | Cincinnati Reds | 2B |
| 1976 | Mike Schmidt | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | 3B |
| 1976 | Dave Concepcion | National League | Cincinnati Reds | SS |
| 1976 | Garry Maddox | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | OF |
| 1976 | Cesar Cedeno | National League | Houston Astros | OF |
| 1976 | Cesar Geronimo | National League | Cincinnati Reds | OF |
| 1975 | Jim Kaat | American League | Chicago White Sox | P |
| 1975 | Thurman Munson | American League | New York Yankees | C |
| 1975 | George Scott | American League | Milwaukee Brewers | 1B |
| 1975 | Bobby Grich | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 2B |
| 1975 | Brooks Robinson | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 3B |
| 1975 | Mark Belanger | American League | Baltimore Orioles | SS |
| 1975 | Fred Lynn | American League | Boston Red Sox | OF |
| 1975 | Paul Blair | American League | Baltimore Orioles | OF |
| 1975 | Joe Rudi | American League | Oakland A's | OF |
| 1975 | Andy Messersmith | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | P |
| 1975 | Johnny Bench | National League | Cincinnati Reds | C |
| 1975 | Steve Garvey | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | 1B |
| 1975 | Joe Morgan | National League | Cincinnati Reds | 2B |
| 1975 | Ken Reitz | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | 3B |
| 1975 | Dave Concepcion | National League | Cincinnati Reds | SS |
| 1975 | Garry Maddox | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | OF |
| 1975 | Cesar Cedeno | National League | Houston Astros | OF |
| 1975 | Cesar Geronimo | National League | Cincinnati Reds | OF |
| 1974 | Jim Kaat | American League | Chicago White Sox | P |
| 1974 | Thurman Munson | American League | New York Yankees | C |
| 1974 | George Scott | American League | Milwaukee Brewers | 1B |
| 1974 | Bobby Grich | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 2B |
| 1974 | Brooks Robinson | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 3B |
| 1974 | Mark Belanger | American League | Baltimore Orioles | SS |
| 1974 | Amos Otis | American League | Kansas City Royals | OF |
| 1974 | Paul Blair | American League | Baltimore Orioles | OF |
| 1974 | Joe Rudi | American League | Oakland A's | OF |
| 1974 | Andy Messersmith | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | P |
| 1974 | Johnny Bench | National League | Cincinnati Reds | C |
| 1974 | Steve Garvey | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | 1B |
| 1974 | Joe Morgan | National League | Cincinnati Reds | 2B |
| 1974 | Doug Rader | National League | Houston Astros | 3B |
| 1974 | Dave Concepcion | National League | Cincinnati Reds | SS |
| 1974 | Bobby Bonds | National League | San Francisco Giants | OF |
| 1974 | Cesar Cedeno | National League | Houston Astros | OF |
| 1974 | Cesar Geronimo | National League | Cincinnati Reds | OF |
| 1973 | Jim Kaat | American League | Chicago White Sox | P |
| 1973 | Thurman Munson | American League | New York Yankees | C |
| 1973 | George Scott | American League | Milwaukee Brewers | 1B |
| 1973 | Bobby Grich | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 2B |
| 1973 | Brooks Robinson | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 3B |
| 1973 | Mark Belanger | American League | Baltimore Orioles | SS |
| 1973 | Amos Otis | American League | Kansas City Royals | OF |
| 1973 | Paul Blair | American League | Baltimore Orioles | OF |
| 1973 | Mickey Stanley | American League | Detroit Tigers | OF |
| 1973 | Bob Gibson | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | P |
| 1973 | Johnny Bench | National League | Cincinnati Reds | C |
| 1973 | Mike Jorgensen | National League | Montreal Expos | 1B |
| 1973 | Joe Morgan | National League | Cincinnati Reds | 2B |
| 1973 | Doug Rader | National League | Houston Astros | 3B |
| 1973 | Roger Metzger | National League | Houston Astros | SS |
| 1973 | Bobby Bonds | National League | San Francisco Giants | OF |
| 1973 | Cesar Cedeno | National League | Houston Astros | OF |
| 1973 | Willie Davis | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | OF |
| 1972 | Jim Kaat | American League | Minnesota Twins | P |
| 1972 | Carlton Fisk | American League | Boston Red Sox | C |
| 1972 | George Scott | American League | Milwaukee Brewers | 1B |
| 1972 | Doug Griffin | American League | Boston Red Sox | 2B |
| 1972 | Brooks Robinson | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 3B |
| 1972 | Ed Brinkman | American League | Detroit Tigers | SS |
| 1972 | Ken Berry | American League | California Angels | OF |
| 1972 | Paul Blair | American League | Baltimore Orioles | OF |
| 1972 | Bobby Murcer | American League | New York Yankees | OF |
| 1972 | Bob Gibson | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | P |
| 1972 | Johnny Bench | National League | Cincinnati Reds | C |
| 1972 | Wes Parker | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | 1B |
| 1972 | Tommy Helms | National League | Houston Astros | 2B |
| 1972 | Doug Rader | National League | Houston Astros | 3B |
| 1972 | Larry Bowa | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | SS |
| 1972 | Roberto Clemente | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | OF |
| 1972 | Cesar Cedeno | National League | Houston Astros | OF |
| 1972 | Willie Davis | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | OF |
| 1971 | Jim Kaat | American League | Minnesota Twins | P |
| 1971 | Ray Fosse | American League | Cleveland Indians | C |
| 1971 | George Scott | American League | Boston Red Sox | 1B |
| 1971 | Davey Johnson | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 2B |
| 1971 | Brooks Robinson | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 3B |
| 1971 | Mark Belanger | American League | Baltimore Orioles | SS |
| 1971 | Amos Otis | American League | Kansas City Royals | OF |
| 1971 | Paul Blair | American League | Baltimore Orioles | OF |
| 1971 | Carl Yastrzemski | American League | Boston Red Sox | OF |
| 1971 | Bob Gibson | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | P |
| 1971 | Johnny Bench | National League | Cincinnati Reds | C |
| 1971 | Wes Parker | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | 1B |
| 1971 | Tommy Helms | National League | Cincinnati Reds | 2B |
| 1971 | Doug Rader | National League | Houston Astros | 3B |
| 1971 | Bud Harrelson | National League | New York Mets | SS |
| 1971 | Bobby Bonds | National League | San Francisco Giants | OF |
| 1971 | Roberto Clemente | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | OF |
| 1971 | Willie Davis | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | OF |
| 1970 | Jim Kaat | American League | Minnesota Twins | P |
| 1970 | Ray Fosse | American League | Cleveland Indians | C |
| 1970 | Jim Spencer | American League | California Angels | 1B |
| 1970 | Davey Johnson | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 2B |
| 1970 | Brooks Robinson | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 3B |
| 1970 | Mark Belanger | American League | Baltimore Orioles | SS |
| 1970 | Ken Berry | American League | Chicago White Sox | OF |
| 1970 | Paul Blair | American League | Baltimore Orioles | OF |
| 1970 | Mickey Stanley | American League | Detroit Tigers | OF |
| 1970 | Bob Gibson | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | P |
| 1970 | Johnny Bench | National League | Cincinnati Reds | C |
| 1970 | Wes Parker | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | 1B |
| 1970 | Tommy Helms | National League | Cincinnati Reds | 2B |
| 1970 | Doug Rader | National League | Houston Astros | 3B |
| 1970 | Don Kessinger | National League | Chicago Cubs | SS |
| 1970 | Tommie Agee | National League | New York Mets | OF |
| 1970 | Roberto Clemente | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | OF |
| 1970 | Pete Rose | National League | Cincinnati Reds | OF |
| 1969 | Jim Kaat | American League | Minnesota Twins | P |
| 1969 | Bill Freehan | American League | Detroit Tigers | C |
| 1969 | Joe Pepitone | American League | New York Yankees | 1B |
| 1969 | Davey Johnson | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 2B |
| 1969 | Brooks Robinson | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 3B |
| 1969 | Luis Aparicio | American League | Chicago White Sox | SS |
| 1969 | Carl Yastrzemski | American League | Boston Red Sox | OF |
| 1969 | Paul Blair | American League | Baltimore Orioles | OF |
| 1969 | Mickey Stanley | American League | Detroit Tigers | OF |
| 1969 | Bob Gibson | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | P |
| 1969 | Johnny Bench | National League | Cincinnati Reds | C |
| 1969 | Wes Parker | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | 1B |
| 1969 | Felix Millan | National League | Atlanta Braves | 2B |
| 1969 | Clete Boyer | National League | Atlanta Braves | 3B |
| 1969 | Don Kessinger | National League | Chicago Cubs | SS |
| 1969 | Curt Flood | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | OF |
| 1969 | Roberto Clemente | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | OF |
| 1969 | Pete Rose | National League | Cincinnati Reds | OF |
| 1968 | Jim Kaat | American League | Minnesota Twins | P |
| 1968 | Bill Freehan | American League | Detroit Tigers | C |
| 1968 | George Scott | American League | Boston Red Sox | 1B |
| 1968 | Bobby Knoop | American League | California Angels | 2B |
| 1968 | Brooks Robinson | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 3B |
| 1968 | Luis Aparicio | American League | Chicago White Sox | SS |
| 1968 | Carl Yastrzemski | American League | Boston Red Sox | OF |
| 1968 | Reggie Smith | American League | Boston Red Sox | OF |
| 1968 | Mickey Stanley | American League | Detroit Tigers | OF |
| 1968 | Bob Gibson | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | P |
| 1968 | Johnny Bench | National League | Cincinnati Reds | C |
| 1968 | Wes Parker | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | 1B |
| 1968 | Glenn Beckert | National League | Chicago Cubs | 2B |
| 1968 | Ron Santo | National League | Chicago Cubs | 3B |
| 1968 | Dal Maxvill | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | SS |
| 1968 | Curt Flood | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | OF |
| 1968 | Roberto Clemente | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | OF |
| 1968 | Willie Mays | National League | San Francisco Giants | OF |
| 1967 | Jim Kaat | American League | Minnesota Twins | P |
| 1967 | Bill Freehan | American League | Detroit Tigers | C |
| 1967 | George Scott | American League | Boston Red Sox | 1B |
| 1967 | Bobby Knoop | American League | California Angels | 2B |
| 1967 | Brooks Robinson | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 3B |
| 1967 | Jim Fregosi | American League | California Angels | SS |
| 1967 | Carl Yastrzemski | American League | Boston Red Sox | OF |
| 1967 | Paul Blair | American League | Baltimore Orioles | OF |
| 1967 | Al Kaline | American League | Detroit Tigers | OF |
| 1967 | Bob Gibson | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | P |
| 1967 | Randy Hundley | National League | Chicago Cubs | C |
| 1967 | Wes Parker | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | 1B |
| 1967 | Bill Mazeroski | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | 2B |
| 1967 | Ron Santo | National League | Chicago Cubs | 3B |
| 1967 | Gene Alley | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | SS |
| 1967 | Curt Flood | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | OF |
| 1967 | Roberto Clemente | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | OF |
| 1967 | Willie Mays | National League | San Francisco Giants | OF |
| 1966 | Jim Kaat | American League | Minnesota Twins | P |
| 1966 | Bill Freehan | American League | Detroit Tigers | C |
| 1966 | Joe Pepitone | American League | New York Yankees | 1B |
| 1966 | Bobby Knoop | American League | California Angels | 2B |
| 1966 | Brooks Robinson | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 3B |
| 1966 | Luis Aparicio | American League | Chicago White Sox | SS |
| 1966 | Tommie Agee | American League | Chicago White Sox | OF |
| 1966 | Tony Oliva | American League | Minnesota Twins | OF |
| 1966 | Al Kaline | American League | Detroit Tigers | OF |
| 1966 | Bob Gibson | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | P |
| 1966 | Johnny Roseboro | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | C |
| 1966 | Bill White | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | 1B |
| 1966 | Bill Mazeroski | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | 2B |
| 1966 | Ron Santo | National League | Chicago Cubs | 3B |
| 1966 | Gene Alley | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | SS |
| 1966 | Curt Flood | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | OF |
| 1966 | Roberto Clemente | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | OF |
| 1966 | Willie Mays | National League | San Francisco Giants | OF |
| 1965 | Jim Kaat | American League | Minnesota Twins | P |
| 1965 | Bill Freehan | American League | Detroit Tigers | C |
| 1965 | Joe Pepitone | American League | New York Yankees | 1B |
| 1965 | Bobby Richardson | American League | New York Yankees | 2B |
| 1965 | Brooks Robinson | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 3B |
| 1965 | Zoilo Versalles | American League | Minnesota Twins | SS |
| 1965 | Tom Tresh | American League | New York Yankees | OF |
| 1965 | Carl Yastrzemski | American League | Boston Red Sox | OF |
| 1965 | Al Kaline | American League | Detroit Tigers | OF |
| 1965 | Bob Gibson | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | P |
| 1965 | Joe Torre | National League | Milwaukee Brewers | C |
| 1965 | Bill White | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | 1B |
| 1965 | Bill Mazeroski | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | 2B |
| 1965 | Ron Santo | National League | Chicago Cubs | 3B |
| 1965 | Leo Cardenas | National League | Cincinnati Reds | SS |
| 1965 | Curt Flood | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | OF |
| 1965 | Roberto Clemente | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | OF |
| 1965 | Willie Mays | National League | San Francisco Giants | OF |
| 1964 | Jim Kaat | American League | Minnesota Twins | P |
| 1964 | Elston Howard | American League | New York Yankees | C |
| 1964 | Vic Power | American League | Los Angeles Angeles | 1B |
| 1964 | Bobby Richardson | American League | New York Yankees | 2B |
| 1964 | Brooks Robinson | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 3B |
| 1964 | Luis Aparicio | American League | Baltimore Orioles | SS |
| 1964 | Vic Davalillo | American League | Cleveland Indians | OF |
| 1964 | Jim Landis | American League | Chicago White Sox | OF |
| 1964 | Al Kaline | American League | Detroit Tigers | OF |
| 1964 | Bobby Shantz | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | P |
| 1964 | Johnny Edwards | National League | Cincinnati Reds | C |
| 1964 | Bill White | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | 1B |
| 1964 | Bill Mazeroski | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | 2B |
| 1964 | Ron Santo | National League | Chicago Cubs | 3B |
| 1964 | Ruben Amaro | National League | Cincinnati Reds | SS |
| 1964 | Curt Flood | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | OF |
| 1964 | Roberto Clemente | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | OF |
| 1964 | Willie Mays | National League | San Francisco Giants | OF |
| 1963 | Jim Kaat | American League | Minnesota Twins | P |
| 1963 | Elston Howard | American League | New York Yankees | C |
| 1963 | Vic Power | American League | Minnesota Twins | 1B |
| 1963 | Bobby Richardson | American League | New York Yankees | 2B |
| 1963 | Brooks Robinson | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 3B |
| 1963 | Zoilo Versalles | American League | Minnesota Twins | SS |
| 1963 | Carl Yastrzemski | American League | Boston Red Sox | OF |
| 1963 | Jim Landis | American League | Chicago White Sox | OF |
| 1963 | Al Kaline | American League | Detroit Tigers | OF |
| 1963 | Bobby Shantz | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | P |
| 1963 | Johnny Edwards | National League | Cincinnati Reds | C |
| 1963 | Bill White | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | 1B |
| 1963 | Bill Mazeroski | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | 2B |
| 1963 | Ken Boyer | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | 3B |
| 1963 | Bobby Wine | National League | Philadelphia Phillies | SS |
| 1963 | Curt Flood | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | OF |
| 1963 | Roberto Clemente | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | OF |
| 1963 | Willie Mays | National League | San Francisco Giants | OF |
| 1962 | Jim Kaat | American League | Minnesota Twins | P |
| 1962 | Earl Battey | American League | Minnesota Twins | C |
| 1962 | Vic Power | American League | Minnesota Twins | 1B |
| 1962 | Bobby Richardson | American League | New York Yankees | 2B |
| 1962 | Brooks Robinson | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 3B |
| 1962 | Luis Aparicio | American League | Chicago White Sox | SS |
| 1962 | Mickey Mantle | American League | New York Yankees | OF |
| 1962 | Jim Landis | American League | Chicago White Sox | OF |
| 1962 | Al Kaline | American League | Detroit Tigers | OF |
| 1962 | Bobby Shantz | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | P |
| 1962 | Del Crandall | National League | Milwaukee Brewers | C |
| 1962 | Bill White | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | 1B |
| 1962 | Ken Hubbs | National League | Chicago Cubs | 2B |
| 1962 | Jim Davenport | National League | San Francisco Giants | 3B |
| 1962 | Maury Wills | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | SS |
| 1962 | Bill Virdon | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | OF |
| 1962 | Roberto Clemente | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | OF |
| 1962 | Willie Mays | National League | San Francisco Giants | OF |
| 1961 | Frank Lary | American League | Minnesota Twins | P |
| 1961 | Earl Battey | American League | Minnesota Twins | C |
| 1961 | Vic Power | American League | Minnesota Twins | 1B |
| 1961 | Bobby Richardson | American League | New York Yankees | 2B |
| 1961 | Brooks Robinson | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 3B |
| 1961 | Luis Aparicio | American League | Chicago White Sox | SS |
| 1961 | Jim Piersall | American League | Cleveland Indians | OF |
| 1961 | Jim Landis | American League | Chicago White Sox | OF |
| 1961 | Al Kaline | American League | Detroit Tigers | OF |
| 1961 | Bobby Shantz | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | P |
| 1961 | Johnny Roseboro | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | C |
| 1961 | Bill White | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | 1B |
| 1961 | Bill Mazeroski | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | 2B |
| 1961 | Ken Boyer | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | 3B |
| 1961 | Maury Wills | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | SS |
| 1961 | Vada Pinson | National League | Cincinnati Reds | OF |
| 1961 | Roberto Clemente | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | OF |
| 1961 | Willie Mays | National League | San Francisco Giants | OF |
| 1960 | Bobby Shantz | American League | New York Yankees | P |
| 1960 | Earl Battey | American League | Minnesota Twins | C |
| 1960 | Vic Power | American League | Minnesota Twins | 1B |
| 1960 | Nellie Fox | American League | Chicago White Sox | 2B |
| 1960 | Brooks Robinson | American League | Baltimore Orioles | 3B |
| 1960 | Luis Aparicio | American League | Chicago White Sox | SS |
| 1960 | Minnie Minoso | American League | Minnesota Twins | LF |
| 1960 | Jim Landis | American League | Chicago White Sox | CF |
| 1960 | Roger Maris | American League | New York Yankees | RF |
| 1960 | Harvey Haddix | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | P |
| 1960 | Del Crandall | National League | Milwaukee Brewers | C |
| 1960 | Bill White | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | 1B |
| 1960 | Bill Mazeroski | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | 2B |
| 1960 | Ken Boyer | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | 3B |
| 1960 | Ernie Banks | National League | Chicago Cubs | SS |
| 1960 | Wally Moon | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | LF |
| 1960 | Willie Mays | National League | San Francisco Giants | CF |
| 1960 | Hank Aaron | National League | Milwaukee Brewers | RF |
| 1959 | Bobby Shantz | American League | New York Yankees | P |
| 1959 | Sherm Lollar | American League | Chicago White Sox | C |
| 1959 | Vic Power | American League | Minnesota Twins | 1B |
| 1959 | Nellie Fox | American League | Chicago White Sox | 2B |
| 1959 | Frank Malzone | American League | Boston Red Sox | 3B |
| 1959 | Luis Aparicio | American League | Chicago White Sox | SS |
| 1959 | Minnie Minoso | American League | Minnesota Twins | LF |
| 1959 | Al Kaline | American League | Detroit Tigers | CF |
| 1959 | Jackie Jensen | American League | Boston Red Sox | RF |
| 1959 | Harvey Haddix | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | P |
| 1959 | Del Crandall | National League | Milwaukee Brewers | C |
| 1959 | Gil Hodges | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | 1B |
| 1959 | Charlie Neal | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | 2B |
| 1959 | Ken Boyer | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | 3B |
| 1959 | Roy McMillan | National League | Cincinnati Reds | SS |
| 1959 | Jackie Brandt | National League | San Francisco Giants | LF |
| 1959 | Willie Mays | National League | San Francisco Giants | CF |
| 1959 | Hank Aaron | National League | Milwaukee Brewers | RF |
| 1958 | Bobby Shantz | American League | New York Yankees | P |
| 1958 | Sherm Lollar | American League | Chicago White Sox | C |
| 1958 | Vic Power | American League | Minnesota Twins | 1B |
| 1958 | Frank Bolling | American League | Detroit Tigers | 2B |
| 1958 | Frank Malzone | American League | Boston Red Sox | 3B |
| 1958 | Luis Aparicio | American League | Chicago White Sox | SS |
| 1958 | Norm Siebern | American League | New York Yankees | LF |
| 1958 | Jim Piersall | American League | Boston Red Sox | CF |
| 1958 | Al Kaline | American League | Detroit Tigers | RF |
| 1958 | Harvey Haddix | National League | Cincinnati Reds | P |
| 1958 | Del Crandall | National League | Milwaukee Brewers | C |
| 1958 | Gil Hodges | National League | Los Angeles Dodgers | 1B |
| 1958 | Bill Mazeroski | National League | Pittsburgh Pirates | 2B |
| 1958 | Ken Boyer | National League | St. Louis Cardinals | 3B |
| 1958 | Roy McMillan | National League | Cincinnati Reds | SS |
| 1958 | Frank Robinson | National League | Cincinnati Reds | LF |
| 1958 | Willie Mays | National League | San Francisco Giants | CF |
| 1958 | Hank Aaron | National League | Milwaukee Brewers | RF |
| 1957 | Bobby Shantz | both | New York Yankees | P |
| 1957 | Sherm Lollar | both | Chicago White Sox | C |
| 1957 | Gil Hodges | both | Brooklyn Dodgers | 1B |
| 1957 | Nellie Fox | both | Chicago White Sox | 2B |
| 1957 | Frank Malzone | both | Boston Red Sox | 3B |
| 1957 | Roy McMillan | both | Cincinnati Reds | SS |
| 1957 | Minnie Minoso | both | Cleveland Indians | LF |
| 1957 | Willie Mays | both | New York Mets | CF |
| 1957 | Al Kaline | both | Detroit Tigers | RF |
| American League | ||||
| Player | American League | Team | Pos. |