Manager of the Year
| Year | League | Award Winner | Team |
| 2007 | American League | Eric Wedge | Cleveland Indians |
| 2007 | National League | Bob Melvin | Arizona Diamondbacks |
| 2006 | American League | Jim Leyland | Detroit Tigers |
| 2006 | National League | Joe Girardi | Florida Marlins |
| 2005 | American League | Ozzie Guillen | Chicago White Sox |
| 2005 | National League | Bobby Cox | Atlanta Braves |
| 2004 | American League | Buck Showalter | Texas Rangers |
| 2004 | National League | Bobby Cox | Atlanta Braves |
| 2003 | American League | Tony Peña | Kansas City Royals |
| 2003 | National League | Jack McKeon | Florida Marlins |
| 2002 | American League | Mike Scioscia | Anaheim Angels |
| 2002 | National League | Tony La Russa | St. Louis Cardinals |
| 2001 | American League | Lou Piniella | Seattle Mariners |
| 2001 | National League | Larry Bowa | Philadelphia Phillies |
| 2000 | American League | Jerry Manuel | Chicago White Sox |
| 2000 | National League | Dusty Baker | San Francisco Giants |
| 1999 | American League | Jimy Williams | Boston Red Sox |
| 1999 | National League | Jack McKeon | Cincinnati Reds |
| 1998 | American League | Joe Torre | New York Yankees |
| 1998 | National League | Larry Dierker | Houston Astros |
| 1997 | American League | Davey Johnson | Baltimore Orioles |
| 1997 | National League | Dusty Baker | San Francisco Giants |
| 1996 | American League | Joe Torre | New York Yankees |
| 1996 | National League | Bruce Bochy | San Diego Padres |
| 1995 | American League | Lou Piniella | Seattle Mariners |
| 1995 | National League | Don Baylor | Colorado Rockies |
| 1994 | American League | Buck Showalter | New York Yankees |
| 1994 | National League | Felipe Alou | Montreal Expos |
| 1993 | American League | Gene Lamont | Chicago White Sox |
| 1993 | National League | Dusty Baker | San Francisco Giants |
| 1992 | American League | Tony La Russa | Oakland A's |
| 1992 | National League | Jim Leyland | Pittsburgh Pirates |
| 1991 | American League | Tom Kelly | Minnesota Twins |
| 1991 | National League | Bobby Cox | Atlanta Braves |
| 1990 | American League | Jeff Torborg | Chicago White Sox |
| 1990 | National League | Jim Leyland | Pittsburgh Pirates |
| 1989 | American League | Frank Robinson | Baltimore Orioles |
| 1989 | National League | Don Zimmer | Chicago Cubs |
| 1988 | American League | Tony La Russa | Oakland A's |
| 1988 | National League | Tommy Lasorda | Los Angeles Dodgers |
| 1987 | American League | Sparky Anderson | Detroit Tigers |
| 1987 | National League | Buck Rodgers | Montreal Expos |
| 1986 | American League | John McNamara | Boston Red Sox |
| 1986 | National League | Hal Lanier | Houston Astros |
| 1985 | American League | Bobby Cox | Toronto Blue Jays |
| 1985 | National League | Whitey Herzog | St. Louis Cardinals |
| 1984 | American League | Sparky Anderson | Detroit Tigers |
| 1984 | National League | Jim Frey | Chicago Cubs |
| 1983 | American League | Tony La Russa | Chicago White Sox |
| 1983 | National League | Tommy Lasorda | Los Angeles Dodgers |
| American League | Johnny Oates | Texas Rangers |